| Platinum | Fish House Grill |
| Gold | Cape Fear Seafood Company |
| Silver | Catch Restaurant |
| Bronze | Fish Bites Seafood Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Elijah's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Hieronymus Seafood Restaurant & Oyster Bar |
| Top Pick | Motts Channel Seafood |
| Top Pick | Seaview Crab Company Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Shuckin Shack |
| Top Pick | Something Fishy Seafood |