| Platinum | A Taste of Italy |
| Gold | Jason's Deli |
| Silver | Cousins Italian Deli |
| Bronze | The Butchers Market |
| Top Pick | David's Deli & Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Gnome Nom Nom |
| Top Pick | Gnome Nom Nom Deli - Morning Treats Afternoon Eats |
| Top Pick | The Honey Baked Ham Company |