| Platinum | Burney's Sweets & More |
| Gold | Apple Annie's Bake Shop |
| Silver | The Peppered Cupcake |
| Bronze | One Belle Bakery |
| Top Pick | Hot Pink Cake Stand |
| Top Pick | Imaginary Cakes |
| Top Pick | Justabitewilmington |
| Top Pick | Sweet Mountain Dainties |
| Top Pick | The Jelly Cabinet |
| Top Pick | The Sweet Shoppe At Porters Neck |